The Ethics of Victimhood: How Democratic Citizens Should Resist Oppression
This book project develops a democratic ethics of resistance centered on the ethical questions faced by citizens who experience oppression: how should they resist injustice, and how should they relate to their fellow citizens in doing so? It examines how oppressed citizens can draw on their experiences of victimhood as a source of political agency, when provocative forms of resistance are justified, and how they should navigate emotions such as anger as democratic citizens. The project also considers the responsibilities of fellow citizens who are implicated in, confronted by, or unsettled by such resistance. In particular, the book investigates the epistemic humility required of both those who resist oppression and those who encounter their resistance. In doing so, it connects the ethics of resistance to broader questions about victimhood, emotion, social epistemology, and democratic citizenship.
Jeong, Jihyun. 2026. "Victimhood as a Positive Political Resource." European Journal of Political Theory, 25(3), 367-387. https://doi.org/10.1177/14748851241308809
Abstract: Victimhood is commonly deemed negative. The dominant account of victimhood argues that leveraging victimhood involves asserting the moral superiority of the weak, leading to an oversimplification of complex political matters into moral binaries of good versus evil. According to this perspective, victimhood traps victims in a perennial position of weakness, thereby diminishing their agency. This paper challenges this negative perspective and argues that victimhood can enhance agency, serving as a positive political resource. When victimhood involves the acknowledgment of inherent vulnerability shared by all individuals, whether they are victims or non-victims, and concerns the unjust distributions of vulnerability experiences, it can empower individuals to overcome excessive self-doubt and transform their victimization into a political agenda. By examining the subway protests organized by Korean Solidarity Against Disability Discrimination activists, I demonstrate how recognizing the agency-enhancing potential of victimhood helps us better understand the political significance of these actions.
Keywords: victimhood; vulnerability; protest; disability; agency
Manuscript Invited to Revise & Resubmit
"What Does Provocative Resistance Communicate?" Revise and Resubmit, American Journal of Political Science
Abstract: Disruptive or offensive resistance makes audiences uncomfortable. Existing accounts ask whether discomfort helps or hinders communication, treating it as a cost to persuasion or a means of disclosure, acknowledgment, or leverage. I argue this instrumental framing overlooks another possibility: discomfort itself may be part of what resistance communicates. Drawing on disability-rights protests and radical feminist activism in South Korea, I argue provocative resistance gives privileged audiences partial, mediated affective knowledge: embodied, first-personal knowledge of what oppressive harms feel like. This knowledge has non-instrumental epistemic value. Communicating it breaches affective insulation, narrowing socially produced asymmetries in access to politically relevant experience without relying on audiences’ voluntary affective engagement. It can also deepen interpretive understanding and improve judgments about the severity of oppressive harms, though these instrumental benefits are contingent. This affective-epistemic relation generates ethical responsibilities centered on epistemic humility. This account calls for a more comprehensive normative assessment of provocative tactics.
Keywords: provocative resistance; affective knowledge; affective insulation; epistemic democracy; epistemic humility; ethics of resistance
Working Papers
"Do Governments Have a Responsibility to Support Counter-Speech?"
Abstract: This paper argues that governments have a responsibility to support the counter-speech of hate speech victims, particularly in institutional settings such as schools and workplaces. Hate speech can silence its targets, especially when they lack the resources to respond effectively. Drawing on Seana Shiffrin's thinker-based theory of freedom of speech, I argue that this silencing undermines victims' moral agency—their ability to develop and express personal perspectives, beliefs, and principles through speech—particularly in contexts crucial to individual development and social participation. Because safeguarding moral agency is a fundamental governmental responsibility, addressing the silencing effects of hate speech is essential. However, punitive measures against hate speech are inconsistent with the thinker-based framework. I therefore propose a policy approach centered on supporting victims' counter-speech. To illustrate how this responsibility might be fulfilled, I refine Katherine Gelber’s "speaking back" policy, which calls on governments to provide institutional, material, and educational support to enable victims to respond. I suggest two theoretical modifications: first, the thinker-based framework offers a stronger normative foundation for this policy than Gelber’s reliance on the capabilities approach; second, it should consider the possibility that counter-speech may itself take the form of hate speech.
Keywords: hate speech; counter-speech; speaking back policy; freedom of speech; thinker-based theory
"Merit, Reaction Qualifications, and Good Work" (in progress)
"Rethinking Resistance: Victimhood and Agency in Feminist Perspective" (in progress; invited chapter for an edited volume)